Willie Mae’s Scotch House

My love of fried chicken has been well documented on this site. My love of travel is alluded to frequently here, and honestly, traveling for food is pretty much the norm for me.

Which leads me to my trip to New Orleans the second week of May. Partially to visit my lovely friend Jenn, partially to eat a lot.

Mostly to eat a lot.

Jenn came to pick me up from the airport and took me straight to Willie Mae’s Scotch House, where I’d read a number of articles proclaiming it the best fried chicken in the country.

Wutttttt? Of course I had to go and see what was what. Because of the early hour – I landed around 10, we got there about 11, 11:30 – there was absolutely no wait. Which is great, because I hate waiting, and it was much more humid than I’d expected it to be – and waiting is done entirely outside the restaurant, since there’s no foyer or really a hostess stand area.

Willie Mae Scotch House-4.jpg

We quickly placed our orders; when asked what kind of bread we wanted, Jenn responded cornbread. I declined any, as I knew I’d have trouble eating all that I ordered, plus I don’t love cornbread that much. I did try a small bite of hers as she graciously offered, and it was tasty. But I saved room for the main event…

Willie Mae Scotch House-5.jpg

Jenn’s fried catfish came quickly, overflowing the plate – look how HUGE that piece is! – fried expertly. Auspicious – the crust was a little too peppery for me, but it was well-seasoned and pretty tasty. Just way too much for one portion!

Willie Mae Scotch House-6.jpg

You get your choice of sides, and Jenn chose red beans and rice. I’m not sure you can completely understand scale here; she took a few bites to sample it but most of it went home with us because this is just a large plate with red beans and then a scoop of rice on top.

Willie Mae Scotch House-7.jpg

For my side, I chose butterbeans and rice after our very friendly, nice server told me that was her favorite side. Creamy – to the point where the beans had been practically creamed – lots of onion, and a bit of chile pepper to give it a little kick – I pretty much scraped the plate. I thoroughly enjoyed this and wonder why I don’t see this on more menus; it was a very hearty and delicious accompaniment to my fried chicken. Very tasty.

Willie Mae Scotch House-10.jpg

This picture is after I ate a bunch of the sweet potato fries already. I’m not sure what possessed me to add these on – I don’t care for sweet potatoes that much – but these were kind of sad. Not crisp, not particularly well-seasoned nor flavorful, they were just… okay. Oh well.

And the main event…

Willie Mae Scotch House-8.jpg Willie Mae Scotch House-9.jpg


I asked for all dark meat, and our server said no problem – though what showed up was a thigh, a drumstick, and a wing. No big deal – I just didn’t want a breast. And I definitely wanted a thigh.

Crisp exterior. Lightly battered, with the thinnest crust ever, and a juicy, moist interior.

Very, very good fried chicken indeed. The best in America? Well, this is going to be tricky. It’s very, very good fried chicken. Extremely tasty. But this is not, personally, fried chicken that I’d want on a very regular basis. Were I to live in the same city, it would certainly be in the rotation, but out of every 5 times I had fried chicken, I’d want this one maybe once. Why? This is a different style of fried chicken; I like mine simply floured and fried. You may wonder at the difference, but there is a distinct difference to fried chicken that’s been battered. I enjoyed my pieces greatly – and happily ate the thigh and drumstick (I kind of forced Jenn to eat the wing), considering it excellent fried chicken.

Just not my daily, go-to fried chicken.

That’s still Bobwhite. I go there more often than I care to admit… and it’s my “daily” fried chicken, without a doubt.

I will admit, however, that considering the secret recipe for Willie Mae’s… I started pondering what’s in the batter and I have plans/ideas for attempting to recreate it at home one day very soon. Not because I crave it, but just to see if I can.

Willie Mae, I tip my hat to you, good lady; you make excellent fried chicken.

Willie Mae's Scotch House on Urbanspoon

Willie Mae’s Scotch HouseWillie Mae's Scotch House


  1. CheeeeEEEEse says

    Good looking chicken. Too bad it didn’t live up to the hype.

    Everything I’ve heard is that the red beans and rice is the go-to side, but I’m glad you got something you enjoyed.

    On another note, that is a freakishly large fillet of catfish, and I am partial to a peppery cornmeal crust.

    • says

      I tend to trust my server for what side to order, though it’s true all the reviews I’ve seen have mentioned the red beans and rice. I’m glad I got the butter beans though; it’s definitely not something I see up here so it was a nice change too.

  2. SkippyMom says

    OMGosh, I totally forgot to tell you we had our annual “Fried Chicken Festival” here last weekend. Gordonsville, which is in the county of Orange, where we live, and only 15 minutes away, has a long and loving history with fried chicken and was for quite a long time known as the Best Fried Chicken in the Country. Now this was back before, during and after the Civil War, and the country was much smaller, BUT it is their claim to fame and a often told story around these parts.

    Since it is such a small town, surrounded by small towns, you can imagine the turn out was good, but probably 1/2 of 1 percent the total number of people who visit Central Park on a Spring Saturday – to give you an idea of turnout. Still – the fry it with pride, with the original recipe, and I can say, it is pretty damn tasty.

    And a deal . But as my family said – that’s really good Mom, but I still like yours better. Which leads me to two conclusions 1. You and I have to meet in a kitchen somewhere so I can make you thighs and legs to your hearts content and 2. Next year I am entering the Fried Chicken contest in Gordonsville. :)

    Can’t wait to hear more about NOLA. Love that place and the food….glorious food. Hugs sweetie

  3. Tracie says

    I’ve eaten at Willie Mae’s and the chicken’s really good. But the BEST I’ve ever eaten is The Old General Store in Lorman, Mississippi, which is about two hours outside of NOLA. It’s seasoned just right, moist and has just the right amount of crunch– so freakin’ awesome! It’s also served buffet style so you can have as much as you want. The owner is a hoot and super friendly. But whatever you do, don’t bother with his cornbread. He may serenade you with a song about his grandmother being a “cornbread queen,” but the taste and texture is closer to cotton than cornmeal.

  4. says

    My my. That certainly looks like some very good fried chicken. I’m not as picky as you when it comes to batter/breading/flour. I just want good.

    • says

      Everyone’s perception/idea of ‘good’ is different. I’m not a huge fan of batter or breading, I like it to be simply fried. Having said that, if it tastes good, I’m happy!

  5. says

    I just ate at Willie Mae’s this morning for an early lunch before flying home.
    This is some of NOLA neighborhood local dining at its best.
    1.SHATTERINGLY CRISP fried chicken. Light breading comes from some cornmeal in the breading I’m told.
    2.The most amazing and creamy, herbed, tasty.. and dare I say unctuous… plate of butter beans and rice. This dish is served on a wide shallow plate..not a bowl. Perfect portion..but I could make an entire lunch of it if it was in a deep dish. My only regret is not being able to try the other menu items.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>