The Feisty Foodie

Opinionated Food Critic

  • Around NYC
    • Brooklyn
      • Bay Ridge
    • Bronx
    • Downtown Lunch
    • Long Island Eats
    • Manhattan
      • Chelsea
      • Chinatown
      • East Village
      • Financial District
      • Flatiron District
      • Gramercy
      • Greenwich Village
      • Hell’s Kitchen
      • Lower East Side
      • Midtown
      • Murray Hill
      • SoHo
      • Tribeca
      • Upper East Side
      • Upper West Side
      • West Village
    • Queens
      • Astoria
      • Bayside
      • Corona
      • Elmhurst
      • Flushing
      • Elmhurst
      • Flushing
      • Forest Hills
      • Howard Beach
      • Jackson Heights
      • Kew Gardens
  • Cuisine
    • Africa
      • Moroccan
    • Americas
      • American
      • Argentinian
      • Brazilian
      • Cajun
      • Canadian
      • Creole
      • Cuban
      • Hawaiian
      • Mexican
      • New American
      • Southwestern
    • Asia
      • Cambodian
      • Chinese
      • Filipino
      • Indian
      • Indonesian
      • Japanese
      • Korean
      • Malaysian
      • Russian
      • Thai
      • Ukrainian
      • Vietnamese
    • Europe
      • Austrian
      • Belgian
      • French
      • Greek
      • Italian
      • Lebanese
      • Mediterranean
      • Spanish
      • Turkish
    • Other
      • Fast Food
      • Fusion
      • Tapas
      • Vegetarian
  • Feisty Fun
    • Articles
      • Feisty Bento
    • Baseball
    • BlindBakerNYC
    • Events
      • FF Giveaways
    • Fiction
    • Food Memories
    • Food Services
      • CSA
      • Fresh Direct
      • Ready to Cook
    • Jenn of NEB
    • Product Reviews
    • Project 365
    • Recipe Fridays
    • Serial Thursdays
    • The Beer Boor
    • Tuesdays with TT
  • Recipes
    • Baked Goods
    • BBQ
    • Beef
    • Beverages
    • Breakfast
    • Brunch
    • Chicken
    • Desserts
    • Duck
    • Lamb
    • One Pot Meals
    • Pasta
    • Pork
    • Ramen
    • Sauces
    • Seafood
    • Side Dishes
    • Steak
  • Restaurants
    • Bakeries
    • BBQ
    • Bistro
    • Breakfast
    • Burgers
    • Cheese
    • Deli
    • Desserts
      • Ice cream
    • Pizza
    • Seafood
    • Shabu shabu
    • Steakhouse
      • The Great Steakhouse Tour of NYC
    • Tea
    • Trucks/Carts
    • Wine Bar
  • Stadium Eats
    • Citi Field
    • Citizens Bank Park
    • Nationals Park
    • PNC Park
    • Shea Stadium (Closed)
    • Yankee Stadium
  • Travels
    • Asia
      • Hong Kong
    • Europe
      • England
        • London
      • France
        • Paris
      • Greece
        • Athens
      • Spain
        • Barcelona
      • Turkey
        • Istanbul
    • North America
      • Canada
        • Montreal
      • United States
        • Arizona
          • Phoenix
        • California
          • Los Angeles
          • San Diego
          • San Francisco
        • Connecticut
        • Georgia
        • Hawaii
          • Maui
        • Illinois
          • Chicago
        • Louisiana
          • Baton Rouge
          • New Orleans
        • Maryland
          • Baltimore
        • Massachusetts
          • Boston
        • Nevada
          • Las Vegas
        • New Jersey
        • North Carolina
          • Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill
        • Pennsylvania
          • Philadelphia
          • Pittsburgh
        • Texas
          • Austin
        • Washington
          • Seattle
        • Washington DC
    • South America
      • Argentina
        • Buenos Aires
        • Iguazu Falls
      • Peru

PIE

April 1, 2010 by Feisty Foodie 4 Comments

IMG_1428

BF and I hit up Forbidden Planet fairly frequently for our comic needs, then generally wind up going to a movie at the UA theater right across the street from it.  So a few weeks ago, when we tried to go see Cop Out with TT and CT at the same theater, we of course dropped by Forbidden Planet… but then decided we needed to eat something quickly before the movie started.  He wanted pizza and I remembered passing by this place a number of times, always thinking it was pie, not pizza pie, so we went in…

Pie’s gimmick is that you pay by the pound.  There used to be a pay-by-the-inch place (that’s what she said) somewhere, but I never wound up going there… I wonder if the two concepts are related at all – like maybe someone saw PINCH and decided to do pay-by-the-pound pizza. 

IMG_1423

It was really awkward telling the guy I wanted smaller pieces than he seemed to want to give me.  Whatever, I got some fresh cubed (fresh mozz, tomatoes and basil), some ricotta/prosciutto, and BF ordered a plain and four cheese section.  This plus two drinks and two cookies came to $18… which seems really high for a bit of pizza, no? 

IMG_1425

I bit into the fresh cubed and was really pleased with it.  Super thin crust, bursting with flavor from the mini mozzarella balls, tomatoes, basil… just awesome.  Since this was the first slice I ate, I got really excited for the rest of the pizza. 

IMG_1426

Unfortunately, I hadn’t looked too closely at the prosciutto slices, and thought those were also fresh mozzarella balls.  Nope, that’s ricotta, soft plops of ricotta – which sounds awesome, but tasted awkward and out of place on this pie.  The prosciutto was cooked to an odd color, and BF refused to try some because it looked too weird.  I was seriously disappointed with this slice. 

IMG_1427

An upskirt- the slices were super thin crust but not cracker-like (which I don’t like), and fairly crisp.  Some of the toppings were a bit heavy, so the slices suffered by sagging downwards, but overall, each slice held up well. 

BF didn’t like his four cheese slices however, since one of the cheeses (my guess is gorgonzola) was a bit too pungent for him, but enjoyed his plain slice. 

IMG_1422

He also wanted something sweet to end his meal, so he got two cookies.  He said they were nothing special, fine but not wonderful.  Eh, I didn’t have great hopes for them anyways.  I just like pictures of cookies.  🙂

Yvo says: I don’t really understand the pricing structure of the online menus I found, but it still seems quite pricey for what it is.  However, that fresh cubed – I will definitely be back to eat more of that when I’m in the area and BF wants pizza instead of a restaurant.  It was really good… though I maintain I am no pizza expert, I liked that slice quite a bit.  The location is also quite convenient to places I’m near often.
recommended for that fresh cubed

Pie By the Pound on Urbanspoon

Filed Under: Around NYC, By Name, Cuisine, Europe, Italian, Manhattan, Pizza, Restaurants Tagged With: Pizza

« Project 365: Day 89
Project 365: Day 90 »

Comments

  1. TT says

    March 30, 2010 at 9:24 am

    2 posts in one day, what a treat, but they did happen on the same day so makes sense.

    I am so upset I didn’t get a chance to see Cop Out. No worries. I already preordered the bluray.

    Reply
  2. Aimee S. says

    April 1, 2010 at 9:50 am

    Now I want pizza.

    Reply
  3. T.C. says

    April 1, 2010 at 10:00 am

    Never been to Pinch or Pie. I am curious how they do it by the lb but you say pricey so might as well just hit up a regular pizza joint.

    Reply
  4. donuts4dinner says

    April 6, 2010 at 11:48 am

    Man, my boyfriend and I just ordered a large pizza from Totonno’s the other night that ended up costing us $36(!!!) before tip, so $18 sounds just fine to me. These all sound like great combinations, and the cost structure is interesting, so it’s a shame you weren’t blown away.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Recent Posts

  • Springtime Fun: Wildgrain
  • Hello from Chicago!
  • Holiday Gift Guide 2020
  • Easy Ways to Ease into Becoming an Eco-Friendly Household
  • It’s been a while!
  • Top 5 Luxury Hotels in New York City

Recent Comments

  • Stephanie on Easy Ways to Ease into Becoming an Eco-Friendly Household
  • Holiday Gift Guide 2020 — The Feisty Foodie on Holiday Gift Ideas
  • Holiday Gift Guide 2020 — The Feisty Foodie on Nesting Like a Mother – Slow Cookin’ Up a Storm (Mostly)
  • Lisa on It’s been a while!
  • zizi on Banh Mi Cart
  • Feisty Foodie on It’s been a while!
  • Xerlic on It’s been a while!
  • Daniel on Hop Kee

Tags

365 Bakeries banh mi BBQ Beef beer Blackboard Eats Breakfast Brunch Burgers Chicken Chinese cocktails contest dessert Desserts DLS drinks dumplings Feisty Bento feisty family fried chicken fries giveaway Ice cream Michelin stars noodles One Pot Meals Pasta Pizza Pork press event Ramen Recipe Fridays salad sandwiches Sauces Seafood Steak Sushi tacos trucks/carts TT Vegetarian wings

Copyright © 2025 · Foodie Pro Theme by Shay Bocks · Built on the Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress